“Every illegal agreement is unlawful, but not every unlawful agreement is illegal."
Every illegal agreement is unlawful because it breaks the law. Not every unlawful agreement is illegal because it might just break a rule without being a crime.
When you're learning about contract law, you might come across the terms “unlawful agreement” and “illegal agreement”. It can get confusing because they sound really similar, but they have different meanings and consequences. An illegal agreement refers to agreements that are expressly prohibited by law and involve criminal activity. On the other hand, an unlawful agreement might not break specific laws, but it could go against public policy or ethical standards. Understanding these differences is extremely important for legal studies, and that’s what this blog is all about.
What are Illegal Agreements?
An Illegal Agreement is one that is prohibited by law, considered criminal, or against public policy. It can lead to legal consequences, such as fines or imprisonment because it is against the law.
To better understand illegal contracts, let's look at some examples:
X agrees to sell a house to Y for ₹ 50 lakhs. Both X and Y do what they promised. This is a valid and legal contract. On the other hand, X agrees to sell a house to Y, but they plan to use the house to store illegal weapons. This contract is illegal and cannot be enforced by the court since it involves illegal activities.
Are Illegal agreements void or void ab initio?
Illegal agreements are void ab initio which means void from the start. This means any agreement involving illegal or unlawful activities prohibited by law is invalid from the beginning. Such agreements have no legal effect from the moment they are created, making the terms unenforceable and preventing any party from seeking legal remedies.
Consequences of Illegal Agreements:
Getting into an illegal agreement can lead to criminal charges, fines, or other legal penalties. These agreements can't be enforced under the principle of ex turpi causa, which means if you do something illegal or morally wrong, you can't use the law to protect yourself or gain benefits from it.
Engaging in such agreements not only harms legal integrity but also puts individuals and their associates at significant risk. It’s important to realize that any benefits gained this way are legally and morally wrong.
Illegal Agreements and Consideration:
An agreement without consideration is not automatically illegal. However, it might not be legally enforceable as a contract because consideration is something of value exchanged between parties and is usually required for a contract to be valid in many legal systems.
Without consideration, the agreement is often seen as a promise or a gift rather than a binding contract. This means one party can't sue the other to enforce the terms. Consideration is a fundamental element that supports the mutual exchange in a contract. Generally, both parties must offer something valuable for the agreement to hold up legally.
Can Parties in Illegal Agreements Get Legal Help?
If someone is part of an illegal agreement, they can't go to court for help. The law says that justice must stay pure and won't assist those involved in illegality. No matter if the illegal deal was completed or not, you can't recover anything under it. The rule is strict: illegal agreements can't be enforced in court. If both parties are equally at fault, the defendant has a better chance. This shows that the law won't allow benefits or restitution from illegal deals.
What are Unlawful Agreements?
Unlawful agreements are ones that can be carried out, but the law won't back them up. They aren't always crimes, but they're invalid or can't be enforced because they go against public policy or legal rules.
They might not lead to criminal charges but could mean no legal support or the agreement can't be enforced in court.
An example of an unlawful agreement could be if two companies agree not to hire employees from a certain race or ethnicity. This agreement promotes discrimination, which goes against laws and public policies that protect equal employment opportunities. Such agreements are not enforceable in court because they violate legal standards and can lead to civil penalties for the companies involved.
Unlawful Agreement vs. Illegal Agreement:
| |
Unlawful Agreement
|
Illegal Agreement
|
|
Meaning
|
Can be carried out, but the law won't support them.
|
Involve illegal actions or obligations that can lead to punishment.
|
|
Enforceability
|
Are not always criminal but are void or unenforceable because they go against public policy or legal norms.
|
Are void from the beginning because they harm public interests and are unenforceable under the principle of ex turpi causa.
|
|
Consequences
|
May not lead to criminal penalties but can result in civil consequences or the inability to enforce the agreement in court.
|
Engaging in illegal agreements can lead to criminal charges or fines.
|
|
Example
|
Agreements promoting discrimination or contracts for unethical acts.
|
Contracts for drug trafficking, fraud, murder, and other criminal activities.
|
In conclusion, understanding the distinction between illegal and unlawful agreements is essential for individuals studying contract law. Understanding these variances is crucial for steering clear of contractual issues and ensuring that you are aware of which agreements are permissible and in accordance with the law. Students can approach legal contracts with increased assurance and understanding by comprehending these fundamental concepts.